Ireland shows promising developments with pilot projects and Heat Atlas
Energy for heating constitute roughly 39% of Ireland’s total energy consumption and is supplied primarily through gas boilers. Replacing the entire heating system with renewable alternatives remains a huge challenge, but the decarbonisation can to a large extent be supported through the implementation and utilisation of district heating networks.
The Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland (SEAI) have identified barriers that increases the challenge of widespread deployment of district heating networks in Ireland:
- Ireland has no tradition of district heating – knowledge is lacking across sectors such as public bodies, utility companies and academia
- There are no local utilities – heat is delivered by national level bodies as opposed to municipal bodies
- Regulations – energy policies and regulation are controlled at national level, where past policies have not been designed to consider the alternative of district heating
- No national heat plan– while national plans for e.g. electricity and transport exist, there is no plan dedicated to heat on a national level
However, progress is being made on several fronts:
- District heating pilot projects – two projects are being conducted in the Docklands Area of Dublin City and in Tallaght in South Dublin. The learnings from the projects will be used to launch a scaled-up programme
- National analysis – the SEAI is conducting a comprehensive analysis of the options to decarbonise heating and cooling in Ireland by 2050. The assessment will enhance the knowledge and evidence base of district heating and learnings will be disseminated among industry stakeholders
- Government measures
- Regulatory environment will support district heating development
- Encourage uptake of Combined Heat and Power (CHP) in the marketplace
- Feasibility study on establishing district heating authority and new strategy with targets for district heating will be published by Dublin’s Energy Agency
- All-Island Heat Atlas has been developed by the Irish District Energy Association, mapping the suitability for district heating across Ireland
- The heat atlas has enhanced the evidence base supporting district heating in Ireland, with 35% of heat demand feasible for district heating. Read more here >
- Climate Action Fund EOIs across four district heating projects
A deconstruction of the success of district heating in Denmark
District heating supplies almost two thirds (64%) of all households and over half of the total heat demand in Denmark. In major cities like Copenhagen, the share of households supplied by district heating is as high as 98%. This is achieved with competitive prices, even slightly declining.
The Danish Board of District Heating (DBDH) attempted to deconstruct the success of district heating in the Denmark by taking the views of industry experts. An interesting takeaway was that while most considered technology an important aspect of achieving set goals and targets, it was not regarded as a decisive factor for the success of district heating. Instead, three factors were named by respondents as crucial; namely trust, clear coals and ownership.
Trust can be achieved through democratic ownership in the form of municipal utilities or co-ops where end users are also owners and can exercise control. Furthermore, trust depends on profit regulation, strong consumer protection and transparency. Clear goals need to be set for successful deployment of district heating, such as low heat prices, convenience, sustainability and reliability. Ownership should involve end users to ensure all stakeholders strive towards the same goals.
Current developments in Denmark focus on achieving efficiency in all areas, e.g. by utilising excess industrial heat. A prime example is the collaboration between Facebook and a Danish district heating company where excess heat from a data centre is used to heat Danish homes. Read more here >
Fjord water used for district cooling in Norway
In Norway, renewable sources account for 98% of electricity. Simultaneously, the effort of electrifying vehicles has come a long way with more than half of the fleet now electric. This puts a lot of pressure on the power grid, which is currently one of the big challenges to overcome.
In terms of heat, focus is on waste-to-energy and energy storage units. Excess heat coming out of waste is key for larger cities and covers more than half the demand. A lot of exploration in the area of thermal energy storage is being conducted, as well as the possibility of seasonal storage. Another area which is being explored is integrating large scale production with district heating systems to utilise the heat loss from electrolysis processes as a resource in the circular energy system. A large Nordic data centre development company, Digiplex, is integrating district heating in their strategy – both in Stockholm and in Oslo. See more here >
The Norwegian fjords already boast a famous beauty, and in the area of cooling there are now several cities using fjord water to cool buildings connected to district cooling networks. One example of this is Bergen, which you can see in the video here >
Sweden has ambitious targets to remain a frontrunner for sustainability
Sweden has achieved 65% renewables for heating and cooling, and 30% for transportation. Over half of Swedish heat is supplied by district heating, and an additional 25% comes from heat pumps. The main sources for heat supply in Sweden are biomass, energy-from-waste and ambient and excess heat. The use of fossil fuels for heating purposes is close to 0%. While these achievements are very positive, ambitious targets lie ahead.
Some of the key targets in Sweden’s energy policy include:
- Reach greenhouse gas emission neutrality by 2045 and achieve negative emissions thereafter
- 50% more efficient energy consumption by 2030 compared to 2005
- 100% renewable power by 2040
A promising opportunity to support the targets further is heat recovery in data centres. Stockholm Data Parks (SDP) is an initiative by the City of Stockholm, district heating and cooling provider Stockholm Exergi, power grid operator Ellevio and dark fiber provider Stokab. The initiative originates from a scheme started by Open District Heating in 2014, where companies were approached and asked if they wanted to sell excess or wasted heat.
To achieve heat recovery, SDP provides infrastructure elements at greenfield sites suited for data centre development. The data centre’s servers generate heat, which is captured by heat recovery technology. The heat is then distributed by the existing 2,800km network of district heating pipes underneath Stockholm. This benefits all stakeholders:
- The district heating provider is able to buy heat for a price lower than the cost of producing it
- The data centre gets paid for something that is generally regarded as waste, while offering an increasingly sustainable service
- The city can better achieve its objectives of transitioning to a sustainable energy system
- Heat consumers get a more competitive and sustainable offer
This business model can contribute to the heating of tens of thousands of homes while simultaneously making Stockholm an attractive hub for data centre development.
Fortum is providing district heating solutions for the Tallaght pilot project
As mentioned above, a district heating pilot project is being conducted in the Tallaght area of South Dublin. Fortum is responsible for design, build, operation and maintenance of the district heating network. In the first phase, five buildings will be connected to the network, including the County Hall offices and the main campus building of the Technical University of Dublin Tallaght.
The district heating network in numbers:
- Annual heat consumption, appr. 7000 MWh
- Utilised waste heat from data centre: 2,1 MW
- Heat supply capacity: 3,0 MW 1st phase
- Electric boiler 3 MW as back-up
- DH network length 1,5 km (construction enable more than 10 MW future heat delivery)
Fortum has vast experience from district heating in Finland and beyond, and identifies four key factors contributing to the successful deployment and operation of district heating networks in Finland:
- Efficient network – minimised heat losses and a low need for water replenishment combined with maximum reliability
- Efficient production – high efficiency in heat generation combined with diversified energy solutions such as waste heat recovery and geothermal heat
- Environmental sustainability – high usage of renewable energy sources in the production of heat ensures low emissions
- Financial sustainability – Low heat tariffs and no subsidies
Nordic-Irish collaboration is key for further decarbonisation of heating systems
There are many interesting developments taking place in the area of district heating and cooling in the Nordic and Irish markets. Further collaboration and exchange of knowledge and experience can greatly contribute to overcoming barriers and challenges that exist in respective countries while supporting their ambitions to achieve a more sustainable energy system. The Nordic-Irish webinars provide a platform where the exchange of experiences and knowledge can take place, with the aim of sparking concrete initiatives and collaborative efforts in the district heating industry.
All presentations can be found and downloaded to the right -> and we also encourage you to follow the Nordic-Irish Partnership LinkedIn page > and visit the Partnership’s webpage hosted by the All Ireland Smart Cities Forum >
Speakers at the webinar included:
- Declan Meally, Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland (SEAI)
- Donna Gartland, Codema & Irish District Energy Association (IRDEA)
- Morten Jordt Duedahl, Danish Board of District Heating (DBDH)
- Trygve Mellvang Tomren-Berg, Norwegian District Energy Association
- Paul Westing, Swedish Energy Agency (SEA)
- Julius Lundh, Sustainable Heating & Cooling by Sweden (SHC by Sweden) & Business Sweden
- Kari Lahti, Fortum Finland
To stay updated on news for sustainable heating and cooling, follow us on Twitter and LinkedIn, and subscribe to our Newsletter.
Sweden is at the forefront of decentralised heat networks technology. Our aim for “Sustainable Heating & Cooling by Sweden” is to facilitate knowledge sharing between British, French and Swedish stakeholders and develop and encourage environmental and economic best practice.
To find out how we can help you and your organisation, please contact our London or Paris-based “SHC” teams. We can introduce you to leading consultants, suppliers of technology and services who will be pleased to share know-how of the development of sustainable heating & cooling solutions.